Kennisplatform CROW Online Kennisbank

Heeft u vragen? U kunt ons ook bellen op tel: 0318-695315

Interesse?

Neem een abonnement op Parkeren

Abonnementsinfo
Inloggen
Ontwerpwijzer parkeergarages
Deze tekst is gepubliceerd op 25-01-13

Bijlage III ESPA-checklist

Hieronder volgt de beoordelingslijst voor de ESPA-award zoals deze in 2010 is vastgesteld. Deze lijst wordt regelmatig geactualiseerd. De meest recente lijst is te vinden op de website van de Vexpan (www.vexpan.nl).
De getallen die genoemd worden links naast de totalen voor elk onderdeel zijn de absolute minima voor die onderdelen. Een lager punt kan niet gecompenseerd worden met een veel hoger punt voor een ander onderdeel om zodoende toch nog in aanmerking te kunnen komen voor een award.
ESPA-checklisttype garage
minimum waarde
Final result standaardgoedexcellent
Score summary sections 2–10Max.
score
2Subtotal lighting46 20273542
3Subtotal car entry/exit27 15131726
4Subtotal parking area54 25264252
5Subtotal pedestrian routes10 44610
6Subtotal elevators/stairwells38 17173038
7Subtotal safety/security34 17222429
8Subtotal outside of car park7 1447
9Subtotal comfort and miscellaneous41 10162632
10Subtotal wayfinding23 8111322
11Subtotal energy and environment20 33916
Subtotal300 120143206274
Has the car park achieved pass mark in every section?
yes – continue, no - reject
Total score 2 – 11300 143
Subtotal minus points (M1 – M7)-55 -55
Subtotal bonus points (B1 – B7)28 28
Final score 116
Standard for award
Qualifies for award: yes/no
1Mandatory minimum conditions
If all these conditions are not fully satisfied the car park cannot be considered for an award.
1.1Car park must be for public use
1.2Minimum headroom = 1.90 m
1.3There must be at least one dedicated entry and exit lane although additional tidal flow lanes are allowed
1.4The car park must meet national requirements for disabled parking regarding number, size and position of bays and accessibility for disabled badge holders
1.570% of bays must be at least 2.30 m wide
1.6All vehicular ramps must be unidirectional or at least 6 m wide with lane markings for two way traffic (minimum 7 m width for bidirectional curved ramps with inner circle radius of at least 4.5 m). Ramp width is measured between walls or pillars
1.7Ramp curvature (external radius) (tightest ramp) must be above 8 m
1.8The car park must conform to national fire safety standards
1.9If the car park has paid parking and access control by barriers or gates, there must be an intercom at the pay point/exit point
11.10All vehicle and pedestrian safety barriers must conform to national safety standards
1.11Receipt for payment must be provided when requested
1.12All turning movements must be capable of being completed without reversing (moving in/out the parking bay and cul-de-sacs excluded)
2Lighting (value in Lux) type garage
minimum waarde
See user manual forMax. standaardgoedexcellent
measurementscore 273542
2.1Vehicular entry area; at 1 m height
  • above 300 Lux = 5;
  • between 200-300 Lux = 3;
  • between 120-300 Lux = 2;
  • below 120 Lux = 0
5 335
2.2Entry; at 1 m height near ticket-machine
  • above 200 Lux = 3;
  • between 100 -200 Lux = 2;
  • below 100 Lux = 0
3 333
2.3Exit; at 1 m height near barrier/ ticket-machine
  • above 200 Lux = 3;
  • between 100-200 Lux = 2;
  • below 100 Lux= 0
3 333
2.4At pay-machine; at 1 m height
  • above 200 Lux = 4;
  • between 150-200 Lux = 2;
  • between 100-150 Lux = 1;
  • below 100 Lux = 0;
  • no pay machines: same as exit
4 444
2.5At cashier; at counter height
  • above 200 Lux = 4;
  • between 150-200 Lux = 2;
  • between 100-150 Lux = 1;
  • below 100 Lux = 0;
  • no cashier = 3
4 444
2.6In elevator; at 1 m height
  • above 100 Lux = 4;
  • between 75-100 Lux = 2;
  • between 50-75 Lux = 1;
  • below 50 Lux = 0;
  • no elevator = 3
4 444
2.7In staircases and all other exclusive pedestrian routes; at 1 m height
  • above 150 Lux = 3;
  • between 100-150 Lux = 2;
  • between 50-100 Lux = 1;
  • below 50 Lux = 0
3 223
2.8On parking areas, average of grid
  • above 150 Lux = 20;
  • between 100-150 Lux = 16;
  • between 75-100 Lux = 12;
  • between 50-75 Lux = 8;
  • between 30-50 Lux = 4;
  • below 30 Lux = 0
20 41216
Subtotal lighting4620273542
Max. score46
Min. score20
3Car entry/exit type garage
minimum waarde
Max. standaardgoedexcellent
score 131726
3.1Car park headroom limit identified at entrance
Correct sign at entrance		2
• yes = 1, no = 0 111
Height barrier
• yes = 1, no = 0		 111
3.2The car park should receive one point for each 10 cm of height above 1.9 m up to 2.2 m3 123
3.3Traffic signs to define limited use of facility
  • clear signing = 3
  • incomplete signing = 2
  • no signing = 0
3 223
3.4Information on daily closing time2
• yes = 1, no = 0 111
Scale of charges
• yes = 1, no = 0		 111
3.5Design entry/exit area
Entry/straight (no turn or bend) lane at ticket-machine (within 5 m in advance of ticket slot)		2
• yes = 1, no = 0 111
Exit/straight (no turn or bend) lane at ticket-machine (within 5 m in advance of ticket slot)
• yes = 1, no = 0		 111
3.6What is the lane longitudinal slope at the ticket machine?
  • 0 – 2% (car doesn't move without brake) = 2
  • 2 – 5% = 0
  • Above 5% = − 2
2 --2
3.7Kerb design to avoid damage to average vehicle's wheels
  • yes = 2, no protection = 0
2 -22
3.8Rough surfaces access/egress ramps
  • rough = 1, smooth = 0
1 -11
3.9Access security8
Barrier yes = 1, no = 0 111
Intercom yes = 1, no = 0 111
CCTV yes = 1, no = 0 111
Licence plate recognition
yes = 1, no = 0		 ---
Full height fast closing gates
yes = 1, no = 0		 --1
Staffed access
Entry yes = 1, no = 0		 --1
Exit yes = 2, no = 0 --2
3.10Entry/exit width between structure (per lane)
< 3 m = 0, 3-3.3 m = 1, > 3.3 m = 2		2 112
Subtotal lighting2715131726
Max. score27
Min. score15
4Parking area type garage
minimum waarde
Max. standaardgoedexcellent
score 264252
4.1Pillar design for at least 85% of bays
  • pillar does not intrude into the parking area = 8
  • pillar at beginning of stall = 0
  • pillar next to car door = 0
  • pillar at back of stall but intrudes into the parking area = 4
8 888
4.2Visibility (many/few dead corners, walls in the car park etc.)
good = 4, medium = 2, bad = 0		4 224
4.3Signage for car driver7
Do traffic signs conform to national road code? yes = 1, no = 0 -11
Is signage clear, complete and unambiguous?
Routing and turn signs
• complete... yes = 1, no = 0 -11
• easy to see... yes = 1, no = 0 -11
• unambiguous... yes = 1, no = 0 111
Entry and exit signs
• complete... yes = 1, no = 0 -11
• easy to see... yes = 1, no = 0 -11
• unambiguous... yes = 1, no = 0 111
4.4Parking space markings
Are they clear and contrasting to the deck colour? yes = 1, no = 0		1 111
4.5Are lane markings3
• complete... yes = 1, no = 0 -11
• easy to see... yes = 1, no = 0 --1
• unambiguous... yes = 1, no = 0 111
4.6Do you provide specific guidance and other assistance for handicapped users
  • very good = 3
  • good = 2
  • some/poor = 1
  • none = 0
3 -13
4.7Parking angle at 85% of stalls
  • angle 76 – 90° = 0, angle 45 – 75° = 2
2 ---
4.8Width of stalls (85% of stalls) (parking angle 76 – 90 degrees)
  • width 2.30 m = 0, width 2.35 m = 2
  • width 2.40 m = 4, width 2.45 m = 6
  • width 2.50 m = 8 (Parking angle 45 – 75 degrees)
  • width 2.30 m = 1, width 2.35 m = 3
  • width 2.40 m = 5, width 2.45 m = 8
8 468
4.9Total unit measure of one way isle width and depth of two parking bays, depending on parking angle and bay width
Bay width: 2.50 m / 2.45 m / 2.40 m / 2.35 m / 2.30 m
90°: 16.00 / 16.30 / 16.60 / 16.90 / 17.30
85°: 15.70 / 16.00 / 16.30 / 16.60 / 16.95
80°: 15.40 / 15.70 / 16.00 / 16.30 / 16.60
75°: 14.95 / 15.25 / 15.55 / 15.85 / 16.15
70°: 14.50 / 14.80 / 15.10 / 15.40 / 15.70
65°: 14.40 / 14.40 / 14.55 / 14.80 / 15.10
60°: 14.30 / 14.30 / 14.30 / 14.30 / 14.50
55°: 14.00 / 14.00 / 14.00 / 14.00 / 14.10
50°: 13.75 / 13.75 / 13.75 / 13.75 / 13.75
45°: 13.50 / 13.50 / 13.50 / 13.50 / 13.50
Total unit measure as above qualifies for 3 points
Up to 30 cms less qualifies for 2 points
Up to 60 cms less qualifies for 1 point		3 123
4.10Ramp surface between parking areas
  • rough = 1, smooth = 0, irrelevant = 1
1 111
4.11Ramp longitudinal gradient connecting ramps (not used for parking)
  • < 10% = 3, 10-15% = 1, > 15% = 0
3 133
4.12Ramped floor longitudinal gradient
  • < 5% = 3, 5-7% = 1, > 7% = 0
3 133
4.13Ramp width (carriageway), all ramps measured at narrowest point
  • < 3 m = 0, 3-3.3 m = 1, > 3.3 m = 2 N.B. Curved ramps must be 1 m wider for same score
2 222
4.14Ramp curvature (external radius) curved ramps
  • 8-9 m = 0, 9-10 m = 1, > 10 m = 2
    At dual way ramps this measure refers to the inner lane
2 112
4.15Approach curve to straight ramps
  • < 7.5 m = 0, 7.5-9 m = 1, > 9 m = 2
2 112
4.16Kerb design to avoid damage to average vehicle's wheels
  • yes = 2, no protection = 0
2 -22
Subtotal parking area5425264252
Max. score54
Min. score25
5Pedestrian routes type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
5.1Head room for pedestrians (excl. doors) The car park should receive one point for each 10 cm of height above 1.9 m up to 2.2 m3 223
5.2Separate walking route (i.e. heightened; zebra stripes or colours)
  • yes = 2, no = 0
2 -22
5.3Are doors easy to use?
  • yes, automatic or open = 4
  • easy to open = 2, no = 0
4 224
5.4Is key signing repeated in wheelchair users' line of sight?
  • yes = 1, no = 0
1 --1
Subtotal pedestrian routes1044610
Max. score10
Min. score4
6Elevators/stairwells type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
6.1Availability of elevators from street level
  • no elevators = 0, 1 elevator = 1,
  • 2 + elevators = 5
    If elevators do not serve street level: 0
5 115
6.2Size of elevators
  • more than 8 people = 3
  • 4 – 8 people = 1, no elevators = 0
    If elevators do not serve street level: 0
3 133
6.3Visibility from elevator inside to hall/ parking area
  • no visibility from elevator = 0
  • glazed doors / walls = 3
  • no elevator = 0
3 -33
6.4Level indication in elevator
  • yes = 1, no = 0
2 -11
Level indication in elevator foyer
  • yes = 1, no = 0, no elevator = 0
 -11
6.5Buttons at wheelchair height
  • yes = 1, other = 0
1 -11
6.6Stairwells (visibility and orientation) clear view2
• yes = 1, no = 0, irrelevant = 1 111
level indication
• yes = 1, no = 0, irrelevant = 1		 111
6.7Doors directly to parking area5
• width 90 cm = 0, 90 cm = 1, 90 cm = 2 222
• irrelevant, open = 2
Visibility
• glazed door/wall = 3, no glass = 0		 333
• irrelevant, open = 3
6.8Stairs (incl. heightened visibility of steps)10
• width 1.5 m = 0, 1.5 m = 2 -22
• no hand rail = 0, one = 1, two sides = 2 122
Heightened visibility of steps for people with poor eyesight
• yes = 2, no = 0		 222
Anti-slip surfacing on outdoor stairs
• yes = 2, no = 1		 222
Anti-slip surfacing on indoor stairs
• yes = 2, no = 0		 -22
6.9External openings in stairwell
  • outside window = 2, grilled openings = 2
  • none = 0
  • irrelevant = 2
2 222
6.10Escalators
  • to/from all levels = 5
  • to/from street level = 1
  • no escalators = 0
5 115
Subtotal elevators/stairwells3817173038
Single level car park at ground floor (not open surface) will be honoured 17 points
Max. score38
Min. score17
7Safety/security type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
7.1CCTV = 3, no CCTV = 03 333
7.2Staff surveillance (on-site or remote)
  • yes = 5, no = 0
5 555
7.3CCTV at:8
• car entry: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• car exit: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• pay machine: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• pedestrians (elevator hall):
yes = 1, no = 0		 ---
• stairwells: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
• pedestrian entrances: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• most of parking area: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
• ramps: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
7.4Staff contactable via
intercom at pay machine and/or controlled entries		6 223
• 24/7 = 3
• all access hours if not 24/7 = 2
• part time/not available = 0 --2
Emergency call system in parking area --2
• 24/7 = 3
• all access hours if not 24/7 = 2
• part time/not available = 0
7.5Uniformed staff present and patrolling car park
  • 24/7 = 3
  • during opening hours = 2
  • less than opening hours = 1
  • no = 0
3 -13
7.6Lockable vehicle exit/entry (after opening hours)
  • gate/rolling shutter ≤ 20 cm maximum aperture = 2
  • gate/rolling shutter over 20 cm aperture = 0
  • no provisions = 0
  • irrelevant (24 hours opening) = 2
2 222
7.7Lockable pedestrian exit/entry (after opening hours)
  • door/gate/rolling shutter ≤ 20 cm maximum aperture = 2
  • door/gate/rolling shutter over 20 cm aperture = 0
  • no provisions = 0
  • irrelevant (24 hours opening) = 2
2 222
7.8Pedestrian access controlled by ticket/ pass card when car park open
  • yes = 1, no = 0
1 -11
7.9Grilles on external openings
  • ≤ 20 cm = 2, > 20 cm or no protection = 0
  • irrelevant = 2
2 222
7.10Protection on half levels (railings) Minimum height 90 cm otherwise score 0
  • openings ≤ 12 cm = 2
  • openings > 12 cm or no protection = 0
  • irrelevant = 2
2 222
Subtotal safety/security3417222429
Max. score34
Min. score17
8Outside of car park type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
8.1Guidance sign posting for cars to car park3
Static sign system only
• yes = 2, no = 0 222
Dynamic sign system additionally
• yes = 1, no = 0 --1
8.2Illuminated sign posting at car park entrance2
Signal full/free
• yes = 1, no = 0 111
Indication pedestrian entrance
• yes = 1, no = 0 111
8.3Exit pedestrian signing to key attractions2
• yes = 1, no = 0 --1
Signing to car park pedestrian entrances
• yes = 1, no = 0 --1
Subtotal outside of car park71447
Max. score7
Min. score1
9Comfort and miscellaneous type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
9.1Notice-board at pedestrians entrance/exit showing
Opening hours normal/special		3
• yes = 1, no = 0 111
Scale of charges
• yes = 1, no = 0		 111
Operators terms and conditions
• yes = 1, no = 0		 111
9.2Payment options (pay at exit/pay at pay station)8
• change given: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• accepts coins: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• accepts banknote: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• accepts foreign currency: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
• accepts bank cards: yes = 1, no = 0 111
• payment by mobile phone: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
• accepts other cards: yes = 1, no = 0 -11
Other payment options
• yes = 1 per additional option to a maximum of 11 points for section 9.2 -11
9.3Payment at cashier lodge: yes = 3, no = 03 333
9.4Number of paypoints (barrier controlled car parks)
  • one = 0, more than one = 1
  • one at each pedestrian entrance (excluding fire escapes) = 2
  • one at each pedestrian entrance = 3
    Pay and fisplay
  • one = 0, 1 per 50 spaces = 2
  • 1 per 50 spaces = 3
3 123
9.5Toilets in car park5
• yes = 2, no = 0 -22
• disabled toilet: yes =1, no = 0 -11
• unisex = 0, male/female separated = 1 --1
• attendant: yes = 1, no = 01 --1
9.6City plan in a car park: yes = 1, no = 01 -11
9.7Use of colours/embellishing works4
• coloured pillars = 2, no/concrete grey = 0 222
• coloured walls = 2, no/concrete grey = 0 222
9.8Decoration of vertical surfaces of the parking deck
  • textured = 1
  • painted/coated =
2 111
9.9Extra embellishment4
• artwork: yes = 2, no = 0 ---
• planters: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
• other: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
9.10Mobile phone coverage
  • yes = 2, no = 0
2 -22
9.11Continuity of radio signals
  • yes = 1, no = 0
1 -11
9.12Background music: yes = 2, no = 03 --2
Special for wayfinding: yes = 1, no = 0 ---
9.13Exceptional air quality: yes = 11 ---
9.14Low ventilation noise: yes = 1, no = 01 --1
Subtotal comfort and miscellaneous4110162632
Max. score41
Min. score10
10Wayfinding type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
10.1Identification of vacant parking spaces
Parking level		5
• yes/good = 1, no / bad = 0
Parking row		 --1
• yes/good = 1, no / bad = 0
Stall		 ---
• yes/good = 3, no / bad = 0 --3
10.2Wayfinding (vehicles)6
If car park is more than 400 spaces:
Are floors clearly and separately identified for drivers?
• good = 3, adequate = 2, poor = 1, no = 0 223
Are sub-areas of floors clearly identified for drivers?
• good = 3, adequate = 2, poor = 1, no = 0		 223
If car park less than 400 spaces score 3
10.2Are fire escapes and escape routes clearly marked
  • clear from all locations = 4
  • clear from most locations = 2
  • clear from some locations =1
4 444
10.3Are floor levels clearly marked
  • excellent = 5, good = 3, adequate = 2
  • poor = 1, none = 0
5 235
10.4Is there additional signing or prompts to orient the pedestrian on the parking deck
  • good = 2, some = 1, none = 0
2 112
10.5Use of colours for wayfinding
  • Yes = 1, No = 0
1 -11
Subtotal wayfinding238111322
Max. score23
Min. score8
11Energy and environment type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
11.1Energy saving lighting systems
yes power factor compensation = 1
yes other systems = 3
no = 0		4 134
11.2Movement detection variable lights
yes = 2, no = 0		2 -22
11.3Adaptable lighting for ambient light conditions
yes = 2, no = 0
irrelevant (below ground) = 2		2 -22
11.4Exhaust air filtering
yes = 2, no = 0		2 ---
11.5Waste water separation
yes = 2, no = 0		2 222
11.6Grey water or other water related initiatives
yes = 2, no = 0		2 ---
11.7Appliances for electric vehicles
yes = 2, no = 0		2 --2
11.8Car sharing and similar initiatives
yes = 2, no = 0		2 --2
11.9Other initiatives yes = 2, no = 02 --2
Subtotal energy and environment2033916
Max. score20
Min. score3
MMinus points type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
M.1Presence of graffiti−10
Stairwells
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Elevator
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Toilets
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Parking area
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Outer walls
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
M.2Presence of dirt−10
Stairwells
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Elevator
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Toilets
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Parking area
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Outside of entrance for pedestrians +cars yes = −2, no = 0 2
M.3Poor quality of paint work−8
Stairwells
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Elevator
Parking area
• yes = − 2, no = 0 2
Poor quality horizontal markings
• yes = − 2, no = 0 2
M.4Poor quality/lack of maintenance
(pot holes, damages)		−6
Floors
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Walls
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Evidence of standing water
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
M5Evidence of bad smells−6
Lifts
• yes = −2, no = 0		 2
Stairwells
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
Parking deck
• yes = − 2, no = 0		 2
M.6Over 15% of parking spaces in cul-de-sac without occupancy indication−5 5
M7Various points of criticism (to explain!) [E.g. hollow sound, squeaking tires, annoying visitors] up to −10−10 10
Subtotal minus points−55 55---
Max. score55-
Min. scorenvt
BBonus points type garage
minimum waarde
Max.
score		 standaardgoedexcellent
B.1Extra provisions in car park9
Allow motorcycles
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Lockers for customers' use
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Other aids
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Bicycle rent
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Other driver assistance
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Defibrillator
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
First aid trained staff
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Real time traffic data
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
Other real time accessible information (e.g. local events)
• yes = 1, no = 0 1
B.2Tidal flow at car entry/exit3
• yes = 3, no = 0 3
B.3Turn around possibility for cars before height barrier or full sign to prevent driving back3
• yes = 3, no = 0 3
B.4Customer service desk1 1
• yes = 1, no = 0
B.6Bay markings extend up walls to assist driver2 2
• yes = 2, no = 0
B.7Other positive points e.g. extra services, friendly staff, tiled walls/floors, good fit of the car park in cityscape, up to ten additional bonus points. To be explicitly identified10 10
Subtotal bonus points28 28--